Posts: 436781 Topics: 21986 LOGIN

Favourites

 

Home >> Love & Relationships >> Open Marriage - Can it work?

28.09.2008, 12:32 quote

redelicious
redelicious Joined: 19 Feb 2008 Posts: 1609 Location: United Kingdom, England, Lincolnshire
View user's profile Visit poster's website

rocketgirl wrote:
But Cheeky - if both people in the marriage want to stay together but have other partners, or have a 3some or whatever, then surely there's nothing to be 'moving on' from.
My *own* opinion is as above (no way Pedro!) but I dont see the difference between an open marriage and any other couple looking for others to join them 'for a bit of fun' - the marriage then is just a piece of paper (and in my opinion again not worth the paper its written on) But my personal views are by-the-by here.
So I think Yes an "open marriage" can work, but only if both parties want that.

They can work. One of my dads best mates was in an open marriage for years, they were both happy, but, and I think this is the crunch, it was open from the start, long before they got married.

Sorry Si, but after 12 years in a monogamous relationship, it sounds to me like she wants more than you can give. In my own personal opinion, I don't think it would work for the 2 of you. She just wants a way out, sorry.

ps this is purely my own feeling on the matter.
_________________
"Always look on the bright side of life..... tetum tetumtetumtetum....."

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jHPOzQzk9Qo

 

28.09.2008, 15:53 quote

70

To be honest Si although this whole idea should have needed to be discussed as a couple it sounds like you have no say in the matter as it seems your wife has made the decision for you so you either have to go along with it, or move on.
Seldom a good idea to stay together for the sake of your children, I've seen enough proof of this in the work situations, even very little children sense and know more than adults think.
I hope you can feel some clarity on the matter soon.

 

07.10.2008, 11:42 quote

colkitto

well worn subject..somebody trying to tell us how well open relationships work...aye that will be the day...mostly it's cowardice..people scared to dump/leave/abandon someone they have been glued too for too long...I know..been there...takes time to learn to live on yer own ..AND enjoy it...and I don't mean endless tottie...sites such as these are a Mecca for predatory men, who listen carefully to women who been through difficult time..so they fill in the blanks and bingo!..they have another "victim"..guess it's always been the way ..if only previous generations of men had Internet..lol...keep on trying...

 

08.10.2008, 18:14 quote

ysabel1970

An open relationship is never entirely open....one person at least feels compromised. If you want to be allowed to sleep around, first become single and then you can do what the hell you like! It's not difficult to work out. Neither children nor finances are a good enough reason to stay in a sham relationship.

 

08.10.2008, 18:35 quote

colkitto

ysabel1970 wrote:
An open relationship is never entirely open....one person at least feels compromised. If you want to be allowed to sleep around, first become single and then you can do what the hell you like! It's not difficult to work out. Neither children nor finances are a good enough reason to stay in a sham relationship.



...sounds about right to me...but what do I know...

 

08.10.2008, 18:44 quote

snaithman

My marriage is wide open because it did not work.

 

08.10.2008, 20:47 quote

ysabel1970

colkitto wrote:
ysabel1970 wrote:
An open relationship is never entirely open....one person at least feels compromised. If you want to be allowed to sleep around, first become single and then you can do what the hell you like! It's not difficult to work out. Neither children nor finances are a good enough reason to stay in a sham relationship.



...sounds about right to me...but what do I know...


you probably know as much as the next person....likely a good deal more than most on here

 

08.10.2008, 21:11 quote

jeggae

ysabel1970 wrote:
An open relationship is never entirely open....one person at least feels compromised. If you want to be allowed to sleep around, first become single and then you can do what the hell you like! It's not difficult to work out. Neither children nor finances are a good enough reason to stay in a sham relationship.


That's not strictly true. I know some open relationships where there are no problems.

 

09.10.2008, 06:30 quote

koyelmitra

Well, perception varies but according to me, it can't work.

If the relationship gets boring, better be single & fool around.

 

09.10.2008, 06:41 quote

jeggae

koyelmitra wrote:
Well, perception varies but according to me, it can't work.

If the relationship gets boring, better be single & fool around.


Hmm, the people that make open marriages work tend to have very strong marriages, so what the point in breaking them up?

If these marriages do fail, its often not because of these arrangements.

Maybe the reason some dont really understand these marriages is because some/most people suffer from jealousy in varying degrees??

 

09.10.2008, 06:47 quote

bbones
bbones Joined: 16 Sep 2008 Posts: 1164 Location: United Kingdom, England, London
View user's profile Visit poster's website

some open marriages involves love with other people.. thats bullshit!!!

 

09.10.2008, 19:35 quote

koyelmitra

A very strong marriage doesn't need an outsider to enhance the excitement in bed.Love is just more than having love with multiple people.

Arrangements doesn't make marriage, but a togetherness makes arrangements.The presence of a third person in a marriage ironically means every thing's just over; the togetherness is broken.

You can call me dumb & backward but still, marriages unite two hearts forever, I don't think an "Open" marriage can actually work anywhere else than bed.

 

09.10.2008, 19:47 quote

jeggae

bbones wrote:
some open marriages involves love with other people.. thats bullshit!!!


All open marriages probably involve love with other people mate, that's what they are.

Some people like doing it, and it doesn't affect their marriage. Bit like swingers.

 

09.10.2008, 19:50 quote

wan90

Doesnt it defeat the object of being married?? Confused

Why bother

 

09.10.2008, 19:54 quote

jeggae

wan90 wrote:
Doesnt it defeat the object of being married?? Confused

Why bother


That's for the people that do it to answer. They still love each other, just like having love with other people.

 
 
Jump to:

You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum