Favourites
Most popular topics | Sportsopen/close
- Man U v Spurs score for t... (43)
- Any Liverpool fans want b... (34)
- New football season!... (32)
- why do you support who yo... (32)
- Boxing?... (27)
- Rugby Union anyone into i... (23)
- Lower league teams?... (22)
- For all you boxing fans... (21)
- Roy Keane... (19)
- So who is the greates Foo... (18)
- valentino rossi... (17)
- which is better Rugby or ... (16)
- UFC... (14)
- Biggest English football ... (14)
- Sunderland are going down... (12)
- OH FECKING YES!!!... (11)
- COME ON DERBY!... (11)
- Beckham recalled to Engla... (11)
- FOR SHAME, FOR SHAME... (11)
- MANCHESTER UTD... (10)
- FOA BAGGIEBHOY... (10)
- Ashes fever!... (9)
- Lewis Hamilton....possibl... (9)
- contender for goal of the... (9)
- COME ON ENGLAND... (8)
Latest topics | Sportsopen/close
- West Brom??...
- Undefeated Calzaghe quits...
- Powerlifting and bodybuil...
- calling for snow boarding...
- Aerobics: Never again!...
- The Uefa Champion's Leagu...
- The official Tottenham re...
- What sport do you excel i...
- The Olympics...
- Fantasy Football...
- Rugby or Football?...
- England captain?...
- This is why my football c...
- Who should be England Cap...
- Beckham...
- The Premiership...
- FA CUP... 8553
- FOR SHAME, FOR SHAME... 8553
- Dream Team Footie...
- Biggest English football ...
- So who is the greates Foo...
- Tour de France predicitio...
- The Steve McClaren Song!...
- Should we have lifetime b...
- WHAT ABOUT BIG SAM??? TOO...
Home >> Sports >> Roy Keane
13.06.2006, 07:56 quote
| scotsteen wrote: |
|
well makelele manages to make tackles cleanly and fairly and rarely lets his side down. while hes not as physical as keane, his all round style and skill makes him a better player. |
Roy Keane has more skill than Makelele. Makelele comes off as a bit of a wimp, to me.
13.06.2006, 20:09 quote
Makelele doesn't have that power thing. Keano does.
Keano could lift the team in a second. Makelele can't. Don't get me wrong, Mak is good..just not great.
14.06.2006, 21:50 quote
Makelele wouldn't have the same fear factor or leadership qualities that Keano had. Roy Keane is a competitve winner with an indomnitable spirit. Can't wait to see him get into management now.
15.06.2006, 09:43 quote
| scotsteen wrote: |
|
Well let me try and make this clear cause i think people are misundestanding me. Obviously makelele doesnt match keanes leadership and hardman qualities but hes certainly more of a genuinely skillful football player. Its keanes brutal style and what he deliberately did to that man city player (when he intentionally broke his leg and pretty much ruined the guys career) that i cant forget. I understand why man utd fans praise him but its important to not forget his bad side. |
I think Keano had more skill, too.
It was wrong what Keane did, and i did think badly of him for a while after that, but then i remembered what a great player he was. Even I admit that some of his tackles were a bit full on, but at least he wasn't afraid to do that for his team, instead of pussyfooting around trying to play pretty football.
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum