Favourites
Most popular topics | Musicopen/close
- What are you listening to... (2843)
- Favorite lyrics... (101)
- - Saddest Song in the Wor... (79)
- gigs attended?... (73)
- Name the band... (65)
- Goth Music... (61)
- Are there any guys who sh... (61)
- Bands you really wished y... (51)
- which singer did you have... (49)
- Best cover version ever,... (44)
- Any songs/bands you reall... (43)
- rap?... (43)
- Guess that song quote... (38)
- Music you like... (37)
- Worst Cover Version EVER!... (36)
- Favourite songs?... (34)
- Any favourite music lyric... (34)
- What's Your Favorite Movi... (32)
- fave singers... (29)
- If you could dedicate to ... (29)
- Best Bands EVER and Ever!... (28)
- Festivals... (26)
- SKApunk come on hands up ... (26)
- The Jam to reform without... (26)
- Fancy a free mix cd??... (25)
Latest topics | Musicopen/close
- Irish Bodhran Drums-help ...
- A special message to you ...
- Songs Stuck In Your Head....
- Who's The Man.....or Woma...
- great adds that cheer you...
- Electric Six? Anyone?...
- How do you feel today? *l...
- Any rock lovers?...
- Listening to .....
- What is your favourite B...
- music of the moment ?...
- Manics...
- Last album you bought/dow...
- Do you love any of these ...
- Fave lyrics...
- Trance / Electronic music...
- Michael Jackson...
- Tennant blasts Cowell's X...
- my favorite song...
- Favourite Christmas song...
- Got my DJ equipment...
- Best Music Videos.... 8545
- Name the band...
- Favourite song to dance t...
- who loves heavy/black/dea...
Home >> Music >> SKApunk come on hands up who loves it ;)
16.10.2006, 08:17 quote
lmao i start a thread about happy music and your all not happy ahahahahaa.
Oh and yes i LOVE Reel big fish!!!! lolz
16.10.2006, 15:15 quote
lol i'm sorry crofter but i have to agree with aradon, metal has nothing to do with punk if anything it comes from blues etc, punk is generally political music metal can be like that but in lyrics only.
16.10.2006, 15:46 quote
| moldypeach wrote: |
| lol i'm sorry crofter but i have to agree with aradon, metal has nothing to do with punk if anything it comes from blues etc, punk is generally political music metal can be like that but in lyrics only. |
I have to disagree there, thrash metal owes a lot to punk (and motorhead). Come to think of it, didn't Iron Maiden came from the punk scene?
16.10.2006, 17:46 quote
| whizzer wrote: | ||
I have to disagree there, thrash metal owes a lot to punk (and motorhead). Come to think of it, didn't Iron Maiden came from the punk scene? |
lol ok , im not old enough to know
but i always thought punk was out later than metal 
16.10.2006, 17:53 quote
Depends what you define as metal. If you take the New Wave Of British Heavy Metal (NWOBHM) as the start of metal then punk predates it, however Sabbath was around before punk (but I don't know when they were defined as heavy metal - they almost started the genre themselves...)
16.10.2006, 18:48 quote
They evolved from the punk scene... you tell me Paul Di'Anno is not a punk...
I never said they weren't punk but the speed of the first album is pure punk... Charlot the Harlot definately has that... They just went beyond and actually learnt to play 
17.10.2006, 07:09 quote
| whizzer wrote: |
| Depends what you define as metal. If you take the New Wave Of British Heavy Metal (NWOBHM) as the start of metal then punk predates it, however Sabbath was around before punk (but I don't know when they were defined as heavy metal - they almost started the genre themselves...) |
yeah i do lolz, old metal sabbath etc i grew up with it, hence why i really count metal coming from back then . maybe it's just down to personal opinion
17.10.2006, 07:29 quote
| Aradon wrote: | ||
| Iron maiden punk, LMFAO nice one, maiden are about as rock as you can hope to get, i dont give a shit where rock, metal whatever came from, what it is now is whats being debated, and while they may have some punk influences, they are rock/metal!!
just in case you try and argue heres a quote for you.
maiden are progessive/metal, punk came to light because of that style. |
I think punk was more a reaction against the musical snobs that were around in the 70's. People who got on there high horses and said Deep purple and status Quo etc, were a higher form of music then Reggae and Soul.
Punk Rock was mainly just fun and put a smile back on music that had started to become too serious. It wasn't a reaction against Disco music because it grew out of Disco clubs but we didn't like hippies.
17.10.2006, 22:50 quote
| platty599 wrote: |
| Im currently listenin to Charlotte the Harlot
and let me take this moment to apologise there is definitly punk in there! |
If that's serious then my hat is off to you sir...
yes Maiden is NWOBHM, almost a foundin band, so obviously they are metal...
Anyway, I think we'd all best agree to disagree
18.10.2006, 22:40 quote
| jimmysocks34 wrote: |
| Just said i would list really the three best punk bands ever that may help define what punk is... The Clash, love Pistols and Ramones. They are regarded as the founders of punk and in my view gods! Joe Strummer wrote some of the best lyrics and music i've ever heard.
Sorry but i really dont think iron maiden are punk, it must have been an influence on them but thats all. |
The music the original punks mainly listened to was dub music. I dont really consider the clash to be a punk band, but they were a great group. I saw them in 1978 and they were brilliant.
Punks finished in 1977-78, when Malcolm Mclaren and Vivienne Westwood started selling designer gear down the Kings Road..by 1979-80 real punks no longer existed. It was really a fashion between 1974-78.
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum