Posts: 436771 Topics: 21978 LOGIN

Favourites

 

Home >> World-issues >> Is Karen Matthews a case for eugenics?

05.12.2008, 22:48 quote

rocketgirl

cheekykev wrote:
Alice the lady you knew is a different case altogether, and i can understand her situation .... but shannon mathews mum is a slapper and probably had more kids to get a bigger feckn house and more child benefit.


Thats where the question "by whose morals?" comes in.
Her partners didnt think she was a slapper, and maybe she just ended up with lots of kids because she's too incompetent to understand the basics of birth control? That surely isnt a crime.
The Pro-life brigade will be defending her for not having abortions.... and sapping the nhs that way instead.

 

05.12.2008, 22:54 quote

cheekykev

well i've said my bit about how i feel about karen mathews ....

Hope she gets whats coming to her in prison

 

05.12.2008, 22:55 quote

70

cheekykev wrote:
well i've said my bit about how i feel about karen mathews ....

Hope she gets whats coming to her in prison


She will! no doubt about that.

 

05.12.2008, 22:56 quote

rocketgirl

For what its worth Claudia, I agree! Evil or Very Mad

I cant begin to imagine drugging my kids so I dont have to pay them attention...the mind boggles. Rolling Eyes

 

05.12.2008, 23:00 quote

Cazzabee
Cazzabee Joined: 05 Jan 2006 Posts: 7246 Location: United Kingdom, Scotland, Fife
View user's profile Visit poster's website

Have to disagree with you Alice...her partners did probably see her as a slapper and an easy lay and thats why they went there....Probably didnt want the kids at the end of it but got stuck with it. She is a bit of a bloody minger to be honest ..Whats the saying..you don't look at the fireplace when your poking the fire (or something like that) Very Happy Very Happy Very Happy

I do believe social services have a lot to answer for in this case too. Just as they did in the baby P case. Thank god little Shannon didnt end up like that although she is going to be scarred for life by this experience thats for sure.

Did anybody watch the documentary on BBC1 last night about this???? Was rather interesting.

 

05.12.2008, 23:04 quote

70

I watched it & yes! it was very interesting Confused

 

05.12.2008, 23:10 quote

rocketgirl

But Cazz, which bit about her is a slapper? The fact that she's had alot of partners (apparently only about 5 or 6), or the fact that she's had alot of kids by them, or the fact that she's a useless oxygen thieving dss scrounging waster of an incompetent mother?
Lots of women have lots of partners - here on flirtbox, it has been well discussed that having lots of partners is not automatic qualification of Slapper title, depends on personal opinion ie personal morals - should any woman who has had oooooh lets say more than 4 partners, one nighters or whatever, be labelled slapper and be forced to be sterilised?...which is the point I was making.
I have come across in my past work women who have only ever had one partner and one child and totally useless at parenthood who I would dearly love the social services take the child away from them and force them to be sterilised.
Its always going to be a very grey area.

 

05.12.2008, 23:20 quote

Cazzabee
Cazzabee Joined: 05 Jan 2006 Posts: 7246 Location: United Kingdom, Scotland, Fife
View user's profile Visit poster's website

How many partners and their extended families was it that the police had to investigate??? And that was only the ones she had kids with...think it was 6 they showed on that documentary last night.

I can see your point Alice believe me but sorry and I know its judgemental but from what has been seen and written about this woman from all different sources, she's a slapper in my book. My personal opinion. And in cases such as hers where she obviously can't look after what she's got then, yes they should be steralised (as well as the mother of Baby P & anybody else that was involved) They should never be allowed to have any more kids. They have been proven by a jury to be bad parents so yes it should happen. Take the "choice" away from them. Again my personal opinion. I'm with cheeky on this one.

I'm just surprised that nobody has got to her yet....it definately won't be long before someone does and i hope it bloody hurts!!!

 

05.12.2008, 23:31 quote

rocketgirl

Personally, from a purely emotional point of view (and using my own moral sliderule) I agree with you and Claudia.
But, in the grand scale of things, it just doesnt work that way, does it?
I've just been reading about baby Aisha Allen.
Having been shook to death by her father for crying, he and her mother then had another child which the social services took off them when he got charged with manslaughter for aisha, now the mother's due another baby by another man....both parents have a very low IQ.
It seems their only 'real crime' is that they were both unfortunate enough to be born with low intelligence, and once again slipped through the social services net when if they had been given appropriate help in the first place, they might have cared for aisha alot better and not hurt and killed her, and if not been forced to be sterilised, why not encouraged to do so?
I chose to be sterilised because I had increased chance of having a baby that would be severely disabled and I didnt think it fair on said child, so why not these people?
Not forced, just encouraged. Same as any responsible mother encourages her sexually active offspring to use contraceptives, in effect people with very low IQs are never going to be able to be totally responsible for themselves and need help in making life decisions, and I think a social worker reminding these people to take a daily pill wouldnt go amiss, surely?

 

06.12.2008, 01:07 quote

kadushu

of course there are intelligent people who make poor parents too, such as the millionaire who burnt his mansion down. Equally, there are people of low intelligence who make a good job of parenting

 

06.12.2008, 01:12 quote

funkychick1

i have 2 kids off 2 dads, does that make me a slapper ???? i live for my kids and anyone like that bitch that did that to her daughter should be never allowed to haver children again or be allowed to have contact with any of her others kids ........... end off

 

06.12.2008, 01:36 quote

rocketgirl

kadushu wrote:
of course there are intelligent people who make poor parents too, such as the millionaire who burnt his mansion down. Equally, there are people of low intelligence who make a good job of parenting


Agreed.
He wasnt intelligent enough to keep from spiralling debts, nor was he intelligent enough not to bury his head in the sand and pretend everything was hunkydory.....intelligence has many levels.

And funky, no i'd not say that makes you a slapper !!! but I do think there can be such thing as very intelligent or low intelligent slappers who have dozens of kids by dozens of fathers and love their kids and treat them well.

I actually think this karen matthews....her intelligence (or lack of), financial and social status etc have nothing to do with the bare facts that she is simply an evil woman.

 

06.12.2008, 12:37 quote

baggiebhoy
baggiebhoy Joined: 06 Mar 2008 Posts: 6111 Location: United Kingdom, England, West Midlands
View user's profile Visit poster's website

rocketgirl wrote:
But who decides is an idiot?


If you fail an I.Q. test.

Believe me, there are a few too many 0's knocking around diluting the gene pool Laughing
_________________

 

27.04.2009, 14:13 quote

jimzsta

My god here we go again! this is the second time now in these forums that i find people demanding compulsory sterilization. scAry! If you read some history you wll find that the last time the subject of enforced sterilization (EUGENICS) was used was by Hitler in the 1930's onwards, be careful what you ask for! you might get it! Smile

 

27.04.2009, 14:40 quote

zacktelstar
zacktelstar Joined: 15 Feb 2009 Posts: 878 Location: United Kingdom, Scotland, Edinburgh
View user's profile Visit poster's website

jimzsta wrote:
My god here we go again! this is the second time now in these forums that i find people demanding compulsory sterilization. scAry! If you read some history you wll find that the last time the subject of enforced sterilization (EUGENICS) was used was by Hitler in the 1930's onwards, be careful what you ask for! you might get it! Smile


I don't think it was a serious request!?
Personally I think she's an unpleasant person, and would say there's some (numerous) mental health issues there.

It's interesting how families or relationships own particular ad hoc logic, or modus operandi can potentialy mask people with 'criminal' tendencies, or satisfy their transgresive nature. Only when exposed to Society, does the lunacy finaly reveal itself.
_________________
"The tighter you grasp Lord Vader, the more it will slip through your fingers."

 
 
Jump to:

You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum