Posts: 395320 Topics: 16167 LOGIN

Home >> Sex >> Prostitution should be legalised in this country...

01.08.2006, 16:31 quote

Anonymous

..I think it damn well should be. Clean brothels where the women would be safe from all the nutters out there. Like in europe the women have check ups etc for a clean bill of health. It would make a shed load in taxes for what ever crappy/capitalist goverment was in power. Drugs should be made legal as well, would stop most of the problems associated with the black market overnight. This country is medieval & backward when it comes to things like this, I'm thinking of moving abroad Cool

 

01.08.2006, 16:40 quote

Anonymous

I totally agree with you.!! and amount of 'legal' drugs th at do so much harm well... Exclamation

 

01.08.2006, 21:32 quote

Anonymous

Except, it is always possible for some one on the street to undercut the 'market rate' esp if they are desperate enough or under age.

From an intellectual point of view, I agree with you but from the reality I'm not sure.

Obv legalising will have massive benifits to the majority but will it help the most vunerable ?

 

02.08.2006, 00:39 quote

Kalamity
Kalamity Joined: 09 Jul 2006 Posts: 345 Location: United Kingdom, England, Surrey
View user's profile Visit poster's website

They actually pay tax to the state in Amsterdam and have enforced STI tests every week plus they have security upstairs (my mate found this out when he tried to take pictures in the Red Light District). I'm for it personally, so long as its regulated to certain areas.

Sure would make Wayne Roony a happy man!
_________________
"There comes a time when you look into the mirror and you realize that what you see is all that you'll ever be. Then you accept it... or you kill yourself. Or you stop looking into mirrors."
- Londo Mollari, Babylon 5

 

02.08.2006, 11:13 quote

Anonymous

I totally agree...after living in Amsterdam ad seing how well it works there. Not only would there be all the cash generated from tax, but tourism too.

 

02.08.2006, 14:46 quote

kathy923
kathy923 Joined: 24 Apr 2006 Posts: 454 Location: United Kingdom, England, Greater Manchester
View user's profile Visit poster's website

i agree, it would b v strange living in a country where it was legal, but its the way forward.

 

02.08.2006, 15:11 quote

Anonymous

I'd much rather the market for sex was "undercut" by someone more desperate to beat their competition, than for a girl doing it illegally to go "missing" because she wasn't correctly monitored.

 

03.08.2006, 16:36 quote

Anonymous

swissrebel wrote:
I'd much rather the market for sex was "undercut" by someone more desperate to beat their competition, than for a girl doing it illegally to go "missing" because she wasn't correctly monitored.


What I am saying is that people who are desperate enough will always do it illegally, so you can never escape the 'lack of correct monitoring' situation. Eg. there was (don't know if it is still true) a large number of underage (ie younger than 16) prostitues working in Bradford, they would never be legally allowed to work (obv) so they would have to do it illegally and not be monitored.

I think that prostitution is a symptom of society, it is bad *if* these people have no other option (due to personal circumstance) or are forced to be there.

 

03.08.2006, 16:47 quote

Anonymous

whizzer wrote:
swissrebel wrote:
I'd much rather the market for sex was "undercut" by someone more desperate to beat their competition, than for a girl doing it illegally to go "missing" because she wasn't correctly monitored.


What I am saying is that people who are desperate enough will always do it illegally, so you can never escape the 'lack of correct monitoring' situation. Eg. there was (don't know if it is still true) a large number of underage (ie younger than 16) prostitues working in Bradford, they would never be legally allowed to work (obv) so they would have to do it illegally and not be monitored.

I think that prostitution is a symptom of society, it is bad *if* these people have no other option (due to personal circumstance) or are forced to be there.


If prostitution was legalised, then surely it'd be easier to police those who are doing it illegally? Obviously less people getting arrested for illegal prostitution, would mean more police officers are able to find those who are doing it illegally.

I do agree, you have a very valid point about them never being monitored - but i'm of the belief if you legalise it, the police will be able to focus their attentions more specifically on the underage prostitute and other breaches there would be.

 

03.08.2006, 16:54 quote

Anonymous

swissrebel wrote:
whizzer wrote:
swissrebel wrote:
I'd much rather the market for sex was "undercut" by someone more desperate to beat their competition, than for a girl doing it illegally to go "missing" because she wasn't correctly monitored.


What I am saying is that people who are desperate enough will always do it illegally, so you can never escape the 'lack of correct monitoring' situation. Eg. there was (don't know if it is still true) a large number of underage (ie younger than 16) prostitues working in Bradford, they would never be legally allowed to work (obv) so they would have to do it illegally and not be monitored.

I think that prostitution is a symptom of society, it is bad *if* these people have no other option (due to personal circumstance) or are forced to be there.


If prostitution was legalised, then surely it'd be easier to police those who are doing it illegally? Obviously less people getting arrested for illegal prostitution, would mean more police officers are able to find those who are doing it illegally.

I do agree, you have a very valid point about them never being monitored - but i'm of the belief if you legalise it, the police will be able to focus their attentions more specifically on the underage prostitute and other breaches there would be.


I can't disagree, if only the country was so logical...

 

03.08.2006, 21:44 quote

Anonymous

I'm in total opposition to the legalisation of prostitution and the state organised profiteering and exploitation of women and children. This glamourous, childish image of legalised prostitution should be exposed once and for all. It is seedy, tawdry and soul destroying no matter how you sugar coat it. So prostitution should be legalised? Turned into a respectable profession? One that other people's daughters, mothers and sisters undertake, yes? Nobody we would know! So, which class of girls will get the option to become a whore at the careers day at school, eh?

 

03.08.2006, 21:48 quote

Anonymous

romaine wrote:
I'm in total opposition to the legalisation of prostitution and the state organised profiteering and exploitation of women and children. This glamourous, childish image of legalised prostitution should be exposed once and for all. It is seedy, tawdry and soul destroying no matter how you sugar coat it. So prostitution should be legalised? Turned into a respectable profession? One that other people's daughters, mothers and sisters undertake, yes? Nobody we would know! So, which class of girls will get the option to become a whore at the careers day at school, eh?


We're not sugar-coating it. No matter what your opinion, prostitution is rife in our country - we're just suggesting legalising it, because that way the women who have to resort to these means - and there are women who have to do this - maybe because they're forced into it by a guy who threatens them with violence, or because they have to support kids and can't pay for them with their day jobs - These women, need protecting. Not locking up. They're not criminals, they're just people - the "daughters, mothers and sisters" you mention who are doing it for one reason or another - but harming absolutely nobody doing it.

We legalise it, and the people already doing it can be protected from violence.

Violence is the thing you should be complaining about.

Stop being naive.

 

03.08.2006, 21:51 quote

Anonymous

swissrebel wrote:


We're not sugar-coating it. No matter what your opinion, prostitution is rife in our country - we're just suggesting legalising it, because that way the women who have to resort to these means - and there are women who have to do this - maybe because they're forced into it by a guy who threatens them with violence, or because they have to support kids and can't pay for them with their day jobs - These women, need protecting. Not locking up. They're not criminals, they're just people - the "daughters, mothers and sisters" you mention who are doing it for one reason or another - but harming absolutely nobody doing it.

We legalise it, and the people already doing it can be protected from violence.

Violence is the thing you should be complaining about.

Stop being naive.


I agree with you on this one.

 

04.08.2006, 03:51 quote

Anonymous

romaine wrote:
I'm in total opposition to the legalisation of prostitution and the state organised profiteering and exploitation of women and children. This glamourous, childish image of legalised prostitution should be exposed once and for all. It is seedy, tawdry and soul destroying no matter how you sugar coat it. So prostitution should be legalised? Turned into a respectable profession? One that other people's daughters, mothers and sisters undertake, yes? Nobody we would know! So, which class of girls will get the option to become a whore at the careers day at school, eh?


I don't agree with your opinion but you make some good points, my overall point of my post is about protection, it goes on & shouldn't be brushed under the carpet & left in the hands of criminals, its viewed as a low-life job because low-lifes operate it! If it's legalised it can be monitored & I know not the most 'glamorous' job in the world but would get their fair share of the money & live without fear of contracting some fatal disease, beaten or raped. So on the point of 'glamorous' ..what about escorts? ..judges, doctors, rock stars, hollywood actors have all got access to 'glamorous' high-end hookers & pay a shed load of cash to have these ladies for the night..same job in princible but no-one bats an eye-lid. ps. swissrebel you make some valid points as well & picked up on the main point of my post, its good to see a bit of debating on here.

 

04.08.2006, 23:13 quote

Anonymous

The suggestion that by objecting in principle to the exploitation of women and children within the global sex industry I am being naive is an odd one. Simply because something is "rife" as you put it does not mean it must be culturally acceptable or condoned by legalisation. The fact that you make the links between violence and exploitation shows that those who should be criminalised should be those men who believe that they have an inalienable right to pay for sex. Prostitution will never exist in a hermeticaly sealed vacumn. Its spreads its pernicious links to child prostitution, pornography and violence. Treat it as a business under the spurious guise of it being beneficial to the tax payer, societies send out the message that in such a free economy human life can have very little value. And that overwhelmingly women's lives and those of children are the most valueless. 500.000 women from eastern bloc european countries find themselves in European brothels every year, many of them against their will. The sex trade is second only to the arms and drug trades and is catching up rapidly. Just because it is there don't makeit morally right! So do not criminalise prostitutes, but the men who use them.

 
 
Jump to:

You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum