Has anyone ever been to a really perfect dream island somewhere?

If so, was it really good or just "ok" and would you recommend it?

I went to the Perhentian Islands in Malaysia.

Was the most relaxing place I have ever been to. I went to the larger island of the two and you have to go there by boat and there arn't any roads.

I stayed on the resort side of the island which consisted of a stretch of beach with a few bars and restaurants and beach huts. (one small hotel) I went mainly for the diving which was the BEST

That is the busiest spot on the island however there are lots of smaller coves and such which are much more secluded and away from it all if that's what you like.

Really Beautiful island.

Does Scarborough count ??

a place in the south of the dominican republic which no one knows about...